Jews in Cuba experience religious renaissance
By Melissa Klein
The Journal News
May 26, 2002
Jose Isidoro Barlia was once known as the Jew of Sancti Spiritus.
Thought to be the only Jew in a city of 100,000 in the geographic center of
Cuba, Barlia held fast to his religion despite having no others in town with
whom to celebrate holidays or share a Sabbath meal. So for 20 years, Barlia,
his wife and children boarded a hot bus and traveled four hours to observe the
Sabbath with a Jewish family in a town 90 miles away, then traveled four hours
to return home.
When Barlia's only son was born 15 years ago, there was no way to have a bris,
the Jewish ritual circumcision. There was no mohel left in Cuba who could perform
such a ceremony.
"It was not even an option," Barlia said through a translator this
month.
Today, Barlia and his family are no longer alone. There are 41 Jews in Sancti
Spiritus who hold services for Shabbat, the Jewish Sabbath, and whose children
are studying Hebrew and learning Israeli folk dances.
Such a revival is taking place throughout Cuba as the country's small Jewish
population is returning to practice a religion that some knew only through stories
told by their grandparents. During the past decade, strictures against religion
have eased, allowing Cubans to come back to churches and synagogues without
fear of reprisal.
With no rabbis remaining in Cuba, the Jews who hung on during the three decades
that the country was officially atheist are taking it upon themselves to enlarge
and enrich their community by teaching religious rituals that start at the most
fundamental level.
"We have lost a generation in Cuba," said Dr. Alberto Mechulam Cohen,
director of the Hebrew school at Havana's Beth Shalom synagogue, which is known
as the Patronato. "The kids used to say this is a Jewish church. They didn't
even know the word for synagogue."
The Patronato's sanctuary was once in such disrepair that birds flew in through
broken windows and holes in the roof. Today, it looks like a suburban American
synagogue, its pulpit accented with decorative wood and marble.
Cuba's Jewish renaissance has been accomplished with help from the Jewish community
outside the island nation, which has sent money, visiting rabbis, and teachers.
Jews in the United States have taken up the cause in recent years, and every
month or so, an American group will visit Havana's synagogues, bringing donations
and suitcases full of supplies. Such visits, including one this month by Congregation
B'nai Jeshurun on Manhattan's Upper West Side, are considered religious missions
and are one of the few legal ways to travel to Cuba.
President Bush last week said he would not lift travel constraints for the
American public nor end the 40-year U.S. trade embargo against Cuba unless Fidel
Castro took significant steps toward democracy and economic freedom. He said
the government would facilitate humanitarian assistance to Cuba through religious
and other nongovernmental groups.
The first Jews were said to arrive in Cuba in 1492 with Christopher Columbus.
The largest wave of migration came at the beginning of the 1900s, when Sephardic
Jews, or those of Spanish heritage, came from Turkey, followed by Ashkenazi
Jews from Eastern Europe.
The experience of Havana resident Adela Dworin's family was typical of the
Jewish migration. When her father wanted to leave the then-Polish city of Pinsk
in the 1920s, he could not afford a visa for the United States. Instead, in
1924, he headed for Cuba.
"They saw a small island, 90 miles from the U.S., so they came here,"
Dworin said recently, explaining the island's Jewish heritage to the group from
B'nai Jeshurun. "They thought they would stay here for a short time and
they would be able to get to the U.S. It didn't happen."
The Jewish community grew so large that, during the 1950s, there were five
synagogues in Havana and Jewish elementary schools of every political bent,
from Zionist to secular. There was a Jewish newspaper and some 40 social organizations
catering to adults, children and various professions.
By the 1959 revolution, there were about 15,000 Jews in Cuba.
After Castro took power, businesses were nationalized, and Dworin's father
lost his clothing factory. He wanted to join the exodus to America, but Dworin,
who was then studying law, wanted to stay and see what the revolution would
bring. Her father decided that, if she stayed, the whole family would, too.
Dworin said she made a promise to her father that she would remain active in
the Jewish community. During the next 30 years, she watched her synagogue crumble.
Most of the Jews who remained in Cuba stopped coming to worship, and the building
fell into disrepair.
Although there was never overt religious persecution, there were messages from
the government that communism and religion did not mesh. Entrance forms to universities,
and even some job applications, contained questions on whether or not the applicant
believed in God.
A small group of elderly Cubans, who had nothing to lose, still came to services
at the Patronato and at the city's Orthodox and Sephardic synagogues.
Dworin said large crowds showed up only around Passover, when holiday foods
would arrive from Canada.
"I was angry with them because I only saw them once a year," she
said. "I used to call them gastronomic Jews."
Attendance was so low that it was often impossible to gather a minyan, the
group of 10 men required for prayers.
"We had seven men, three Torahs," Dworin said. "It's a Cuban
minyan."
Jose Levy, the leader of Cuba's Sephardic community, said people felt isolated
from Judaism.
"They sometimes thought, 'OK, nobody is going to help us, nobody will
ever help us,' " Levy said.
The dissolution of the Soviet Union brought profound changes to Cuba, including
an end to most of the country's trade. It also brought a new openness toward
religion and, in 1992, the Communist Congress of Cuba declared that Cubans could
be religious without sacrificing membership in the Communist Party.
That year, Dr. Jose Miller, the head of Patronato, decided to ask for assistance
in reviving the ailing Jewish community. He turned to the American Jewish Joint
Distribution Committee, a charitable agency based in Manhattan that makes restoring
and strengthening Jewish community life one of its missions.
One of the group's first steps was to travel throughout Cuba and determine
how many Jews remained, and where. Most Jews still living in the country had
married outside the religion, leaving few who were born of Jewish mothers and
considered by traditional Jewish law to be Jewish.
Alberto Behar was such a Jew. Behar's father was Jewish but, because of the
revolution, did not participate in Jewish life. When the elder Behar died in
1986, a leader of Havana's Orthodox community told his son he had to say Kaddish,
the Jewish prayer of mourning.
"I didn't know to say the Kaddish," said Behar, a 35-year-old computer
programmer who lives in Havana.
Behar decided to learn about the religion of his grandparents, Turkish immigrants
to Cuba. In 1996, he converted to Judaism and underwent a circumcision, from
which he said it took him three months to recover. The next year, he celebrated
his bar mitzvah.
Behar learned to read the Torah and now chants the Hebrew from the pulpit of
the Patronato in a strong voice.
Such dedication to Judaism is mirrored in Maria Eugenia Esquenazi and her husband,
Efrain Niebla Fuentes, who wake up at 3 a.m. on Saturdays to catch a 4:30 a.m.
bus from their town outside Havana to reach the Patronato in time for Sabbath
services. Esquenazi has Jewish roots on her father's side and hopes to convert
and move to Israel.
For the past seven years, Cuba has quietly allowed Jews to immigrate to Israel,
although the two countries have no formal diplomatic relations. About 500 people
have done so, Levy said.
Although the Cuban government is pro-Palestinian, Jews insist there is no anti-Semitism.
A kosher butcher shop has been allowed to operate with a government allotment
of meat. Castro even visited the Patronato several years ago at Dworin's invitation.
He stunned those gathered in the synagogue's social hall for a Hanukkah celebration.
The Patronato's sanctuary was still in disrepair when the Cuban leader made
his visit. A renovation was completed two years ago, thanks mostly to donations
Dworin coaxed from former schoolmates now living in Miami.
The synagogue still has no money to support a rabbi. The JDC sends a rabbi
several times a year for special occasions such as conversions. The agency is
also funding the two-year stay of a young Argentine couple, Nestor Szewach and
Mara Steiner, who help lead services and coordinate countrywide activities such
as camps for children and senior citizens.
At Havana's Orthodox synagogue, Adath Israel, an older Cuban man, led a recent
morning service, using the Hebrew he had learned as a child. The services are
held in a basement sanctuary because the main sanctuary upstairs needs a new
roof, air conditioning and new carpeting.
"It will take a lot of money," said Luis Rousso, the administrator
of the congregation that operates the kosher butcher shop and runs Cuba's only
mikvah, or ritual bath.
The city's second synagogue, founded in 1914 for the growing wave of Sephardic
Jews to reach the island, was closed eight years ago. Disintegrating prayer
books now sit in glass cabinets, and wooden seats are heaped in piles, broken
and dust-covered. A French architectural firm has expressed interest in renovating
the building and turning it into a museum. Levy said he was awaiting the permission
of the Cuban government to go forward with the project. Services for the community
are now held in a more modern building.
The Cuban Jewish population, which was about 800 in 1980, is now thought to
be more than double that at 1,700. In addition to Havana, there are eight Jewish
communities in the provinces, most of which have no synagogue and hold services
in people's homes.
Marcelo Bronstein, a rabbi from B'nai Jeshurun who led the synagogue's recent
trip, said seeing the resurgence of the Jewish community was a testament to
the resilience of people who, by all logic, could have disappeared.
"People basically assimilated," Bronstein said. "There was no
reason for them to be here now. There was no reason for them to have Shabbat.
There was no reason for them to still be present."
In Sancti Spiritus seven years ago, Jose Barlia, at the prompting of the JDC,
began to find people in his city who had Jewish roots. Some had no idea of their
heritage until he told them, and some were so assimilated that being Jewish
had no meaning.
"It was not easy," said Barlia, a 50-year-old math professor at a
pre-college program.
He eventually found a dozen families and, on June 9, six members of the community
will begin the formal process to convert to Judaism, including Barlia's son,
Jose, whose mother is not Jewish. The teen-ager will eventually have the circumcision
that should have been done at birth.
To Barlia, his joy comes in knowing that his 2-year-old granddaughter, Claudia,
will not have to struggle to be Jewish. She already dances along when the older
children do Israeli folk dances.
It was something, Barlia told Bronstein, that he did not imagine would be possible.
"Suddenly, this granddaughter would have a community and she would learn
Hebrew and dances and things like that," Bronstein said. "That, for
him, is a miracle."